"Fellow Travelers" is a compelling drama series set primarily during the height of the U.S. government’s Cold War-era persecution of communists, "subversives," and LGBTQ+ individuals, and ending amid the devastating HIV/AIDS crisis of the 1980s. The story revolves around the complex, clandestine romance between two men, Hawkins "Hawk" Fuller and Tim Laughlin, whose lives intersect against the backdrop of political turmoil, societal bigotry, and personal struggle.
“Fellow Travelers,” based on Thomas Mallon’s bestselling novel and adapted for television by Ron Nyswaner, is a powerful drama series that spans three decades. Set primarily in Washington, D.C., it explores the profound complexities of a hidden relationship between two men amidst some of the most tumultuous periods in American history.
The series centers on Hawkins “Hawk” Fuller (Matt Bomer), a charismatic federal bureaucrat who conceals his sexuality behind a stoic and hypermasculine facade, and Tim Laughlin (Jonathan Bailey), the naive and idealistic new assistant to Senator Joseph McCarthy (Chris Bauer). The narrative delves into their volatile romance, highlighting the societal and personal challenges they face.
“Fellow Travelers” opens in 1986, with Marcus Hooks (Jelani Alladin) visiting Hawk to deliver a package. This scene transitions the viewer back to 1952, at an election party for President Dwight D. Eisenhower, where Hawk and Tim first meet. Their initial interaction quickly evolves into a secretive and emotionally charged relationship.
The first five episodes, which alternate between 1986 and the early 1950s, are particularly strong. They effectively showcase the destructive impact of McCarthy’s anti-communist and anti-gay purges on individuals and society. The series also provides a detailed look at the inner workings of McCarthy’s office, including the sinister role of Roy Cohn (Will Brill) and his obsession with David Schine (Matt Visser).
Beyond focusing on Hawk and Tim, “Fellow Travelers” expands to include other characters, such as Marcus, a closeted Black journalist, and his partner Frankie Hines (Noah J. Ricketts), a drag queen. Their stories add layers to the narrative, exploring intersections of racism and homophobia, and offering a glimpse into the mid-20th century’s underground culture. The series also examines the perspectives of women in Hawk’s life, such as his secretary Mary Johnson (Erin Neufer) and his wife Lucy Smith (Allison Williams), who navigate their own forms of societal pressure and personal compromise.
However, Episode 6, titled “Beyond Measure,” set in 1968, disrupts the show’s rhythm. The episode’s brief treatment of significant events like the Vietnam War and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination, combined with an 11-year narrative jump, creates a noticeable disjointedness. Despite this, the series regains its footing in the final episodes, culminating in a powerful confrontation between Tim and Hawk as they face their past and the lies they have lived.
The chemistry between Bomer and Bailey is a standout, with their performances bringing depth to the depiction of Hawk and Tim’s relationship. “Fellow Travelers” goes beyond physical attraction, compelling viewers to reflect on historical injustices and personal resilience. It serves as a poignant reminder of the cost of freedom and the sacrifices made for the right to live authentically and without shame.
