In & Out (1997) Review – A Queer Comedy That Tiptoes Through the Closet
Coming Out… by Accident
Howard Brackett is a beloved English teacher in a quiet American town, engaged to a lovely woman, loved by his students… and unexpectedly outed as gay on live television by his former student while accepting an Academy Award. Suddenly, Howard’s whole world turns upside down, and he’s left asking the question: “Wait… am I?”
The Struggle of Being “Not That Kind of Gay”
Kevin Kline shines as Howard – confused, well-mannered, trying desperately to prove his heterosexuality with cassette tapes titled “Exploring Your Masculinity” and disastrous attempts at intimacy. His efforts to stay “normal” only highlight how deep his denial runs. Watching him try to dance “like a real man” to Village People is still pure comedic gold.
Silly, Sweet… and a Bit Too Safe
In & Out (1997) delivers genuine laughs and even heartfelt moments, especially when Tom Selleck shows up as a confident gay reporter and plants a surprise kiss on Howard. But the film pulls its punches — there’s no real exploration of shame, fear, or even queer joy. It’s a comedy that constantly reassures its audience not to worry — it’s all just good fun.
Best Scene? School Spirit, Literally
Let’s be honest: the “I’m gay!” scene, where Howard’s students stand up one by one in solidarity, is cheesy as hell — and yet, it works. It’s camp, it’s corny, and it hits you right in the heart.
What In & Out (1997) Gets Right
It was bold for its time — a mainstream Hollywood comedy about a man questioning his sexuality, surrounded by absurd but lovable characters. While it plays things safe, it opened doors. The film doesn’t land every punch, but it lands some laughs, a little truth, and Kevin Kline in his best confused-gay-teacher mode.
When the Tape Says “Think About Sports”
This film is worth watching just for the scene where Howard yells at his self-help tape for telling him to “think about sports” during sex. Some moments age poorly — others age like fine, rainbow-colored wine.
So, What’s the Verdict?
In & Out (1997) isn’t revolutionary, but it’s warm, funny, and sincere in its own timid way. It flirts with the idea of self-acceptance, but doesn’t quite commit. Still, for 1997, that was something. Watch it for Kevin Kline’s impeccable timing, Tom Selleck’s mustache, and a world where coming out ends with applause and confetti.