What happens when a straight yoga teacher and her gay best friend skip the fertility clinic and try to conceive the old-fashioned way? Gayby turns a wild New York premise into a sharp, genuinely warm comedy about modern families and growing up on your own terms.
If you like smart, slightly neurotic New York indie comedies with a big queer heart, Gayby from 2012 is a total blast. Written and directed by Jonathan Lisecki, who expanded it from his own award winning short film, this movie takes a ridiculous premise and makes it feel surprisingly real, awkward, and sweet.
Jenn and Matt have been best friends since college and are now firmly in their thirties, staring down the reality that their lives are not quite where they expected. Jenn teaches hot yoga and runs errands for her demanding boss, while Matt works at a comic book shop, nursing a broken heart over his ex boyfriend Tom and putting off his dream of writing a graphic novel. Fed up with the New York dating scene, they decide to make good on an old pact and have a baby together.
Skipping the Clinic
Since Jenn refuses to deal with expensive fertility clinics and mix ups, she convinces Matt to do it the old fashioned way. Watching two platonic best friends try to navigate scheduled sex when one of them is a gay man is comedy gold. Jenn Harris and Matthew Wilkas have effortless chemistry, playing off each other with the kind of rapid fire banter you only get from people who have known each other forever.
Eventually, they realize the bedroom route is a bit too weird and switch to a needleless cat medicine syringe borrowed from Matt's hilarious friend Nelson, played scene stealingly well by Jack Ferver. Meanwhile, both of them jump back into online dating, leading to overlapping dates in Matt's apartment and a sweet new romance for Matt with a divorced dad named Scott, played by Mike Doyle.
A Modern Kind of Family
Of course, things do not stay simple for long. Right around the time Jenn actually gets pregnant, a chaotic night fueled by fertility herbs and a handsome house painter throws a huge question mark over who the biological father really is. When Jenn drops that bomb at Matt's birthday party, their friendship hits a genuine wall.
What makes Gayby stand out is that it never turns mean spirited, even when the characters act selfishly or mess up. The forced time apart pushes both Matt and Jenn to finally grow up, take their careers seriously, and figure out what they actually want. By the time they find their way back to each other, you are completely rooting for them and their unconventional little family.

















