Riley (2023): A High School Athlete vs. His Own Truth
Riley (2023) Review: The Game He Can’t Win by Pretending
Riley (2023) is the kind of movie where the loudest thing is what nobody says out loud.
On paper, Dakota Riley is the dream: a high school football guy with a clean blueprint life. You know the type, disciplined, polite, future-ready. Adults love him because he looks like a plan that worked. He has offers, a team, a routine, and a girlfriend named Courtney who is basically the human version of “everything is fine.”
Then the problem arrives.
It’s not a villain. It’s not a scandal. It’s not a secret folder of evil. It’s just a feeling. Quiet at first, louder later, and eventually impossible to ignore, the kind that doesn’t care about your schedule, your reputation, or your dad’s idea of what a “real man” should look like.
Yes, I’ll spoil some things. This movie isn’t about plot twists. It’s about pressure.
The “perfect jock” fantasy is expensive
Control runs Dakota’s whole life. He works, trains, smiles, and does the right thing. At dinner, he even prays with his family like a kid who’s never done anything wrong in his life.
That’s the trap. He believes he has to be good at everything, including being someone he’s not.
Football isn’t just football here. It’s identity. It’s protection. It’s a uniform that says, “don’t ask questions.”
Courtney: the girlfriend who can smell a lie
Courtney isn’t written as a clueless obstacle. She’s sharp. She notices Dakota freezing in moments where he should be present, and she can feel the awkward distance growing between them.
One scene lands like a joke and a warning at the same time: she points out that your social media knows you better than you know yourself. Funny, yes. Also terrifying, because she’s not wrong.
She keeps trying to pull him into something real. Meanwhile, Dakota keeps trying to stay “correct.” Watching him attempt romance is like watching someone attempt math homework: focus, discipline, panic.
Liam: the mirror Dakota refuses to look into
Eventually the film does what it has to do and puts Dakota next to the one person who makes denial impossible: Liam.
At school, Liam gets targeted like a punchline by guys who think homophobia is a personality trait. He’s tough, sharp-tongued, and tired of everyone’s nonsense. Pairing him with Dakota on a French project feels like life doing that thing it loves most: creating chaos and calling it “character development.”
When they’re alone, Liam asks what nobody else dares to say: “Does she know?”
Dakota in Riley (2023) tries to dodge. Liam doesn’t let him.
Then it happens. The line gets crossed, not in a romantic fireworks way, but like a dam finally breaking after holding back too much water for too long.
Closet panic is not romantic, it’s ugly
After that, Dakota doesn’t become a brave hero overnight. He becomes a mess, a believable mess.
Desire isn’t the scariest part. The scariest part is what desire threatens to destroy: his “perfect” image, his position, his future, his dad’s expectations, the entire small-town football-masculinity religion he was raised in.
So he does what a lot of terrified people do. He runs toward anonymity.
There’s a detour with an older hookup, and it’s not there to be sexy. It shows how desperate Dakota is for a version of this that doesn’t require him to be real. He wants the feeling without the consequences, the release without the identity.
Predictably, it goes about as well as you’d expect. He bails like his own body just hit an emergency shut-off button.
The father factor: love, pressure, and that “man up” poison
At home, Dakota’s father isn’t a cartoon monster. He’s something more realistic, and therefore more painful: a parent who thinks he’s protecting his son by pushing him harder into the role.
A constant “don’t embarrass us” energy hangs in the air, even when nobody says those words directly. You can hear it in every expectation, every disappointed look, and in the way masculinity gets treated like a rulebook instead of a human experience.
Riley (2023): And Dakota keeps trying to win. Even here. Even in his own life.
The confession: not a victory speech, just survival
The emotional climax isn’t a grand coming-out moment for the whole school. It’s quieter. It’s personal. It hurts, because it’s honest.
Eventually Dakota sits with Courtney and says the one thing he’s been avoiding since the first scene: he can’t be the boyfriend she deserves. He tried, he really tried, but something in him doesn’t line up with the story he’s been performing.
Then he says it with the kind of caution people use when they’re stepping onto thin ice:
He doesn’t know exactly what label fits. But he knows he’s not straight.
Courtney is devastated, of course. Still, the film gives her dignity. She’s not just there to cry and disappear, she’s there to represent the reality of collateral damage. Sometimes your truth is necessary. Sometimes it still hurts someone who loved you.
Orvel take: why this one works in Riley (2023)
Riley works because it refuses to glamorize the closet. It shows anxiety, self-policing, spiraling, and the emotional damage that comes from trying to be “perfect” at a life that isn’t yours.
Is it comfortable? No, and that’s the point.
This isn’t a movie about realizing you’re gay and instantly becoming enlightened. It’s about the messy middle: panic, denial, half-truths, and those small acts of honesty that slowly add up to freedom.
If you like queer coming-of-age stories that feel raw and real, Riley is worth your time. Not because it’s polished, but because it’s human.

















