Colby, a young gay man, devises a plan to help his homophobic father, Mike, overcome his prejudices by inviting him on a camping trip under the guise of a business meeting. Unbeknownst to Mike, Colby’s boyfriend, Rusty, also joins the trip, posing as the potential business partner. Rusty, flamboyant and outgoing, struggles to "butch it up" to impress Mike, who remains oblivious to his true relationship with Colby. As the trip progresses, both Mike and Rusty face moments of vulnerability, challenging long-held beliefs and slowly revealing their true selves. While the camping trip brings laughter and awkward situations, it also uncovers deeper emotional scars, leading to an unexpected climax that forces Mike to confront his prejudices.
In Winning Dad, a young man tricks his homophobic father into a camping trip with his secret boyfriend, leading to unexpected emotional revelations and a journey of acceptance.
Winning Dad is a refreshing take on the coming-out genre, flipping the traditional narrative by focusing on the father’s journey of growth rather than the son’s. Directed and written by Arthur Allen, this heartfelt drama sheds light on the tension between progress in LGBTQ+ rights and the lingering prejudices that can still fracture families. The film’s premise is both simple and effective: a camping trip where a homophobic father is unknowingly forced to bond with his son’s boyfriend.
Jake Street delivers a strong performance as Colby, the determined son who, in his desire for acceptance, takes a big risk by tricking his father. Arthur Allen, who plays Rusty, brings a mix of humor and vulnerability to the role of the flamboyant boyfriend struggling to fit into the traditional masculine world of Colby’s father. Rusty’s exaggerated attempts to act “straight” are both funny and poignant, reflecting the emotional strain of suppressing one’s true identity. Chuck Sigars, as Mike, shines in his portrayal of a man deeply conflicted by his own prejudices, delivering a performance that’s equal parts frustrating and sympathetic.
The film is visually striking, with the scenic beauty of the Pacific Northwest providing a meditative backdrop to the emotional storm brewing between the characters. The contrast between the serenity of nature and the inner turmoil of the characters enhances the emotional impact of the story.
One of the film’s key strengths is its handling of complex relationships. Rather than portraying Mike as a villain, Winning Dad shows the layers of confusion, fear, and emotional baggage that often accompany deep-seated homophobia. Mike’s journey toward acceptance is slow and painful, and the film wisely avoids quick fixes or easy solutions. Meanwhile, Rusty’s character, while comedic, is given enough depth to showcase the strain that hiding one’s identity can have on a relationship.
The supporting cast, including Ellen McLain as Colby’s mother Lisa and Megan Jackson as his sister Jamie, adds emotional weight to the story, creating a fuller picture of the family dynamics at play. Both women serve as emotional anchors, with Lisa’s quiet compassion and Jamie’s protective nature rounding out the story’s emotional core.
Though Winning Dad is not without its flaws—some scenes feel stretched, and the pacing drags at times—it remains a powerful narrative about the intersections of love, prejudice, and family. The film’s greatest achievement is its ability to balance humor with heart, making it a story about more than just acceptance; it’s about the personal journeys we all must take to overcome ingrained beliefs and grow.
In a world where LGBTQ+ rights have made significant legal progress, Winning Dad reminds viewers that the personal struggles for acceptance, especially within families, are ongoing. The film’s climax is both emotional and thought-provoking, leaving viewers to reflect on the complexities of love and identity. While it may not be a perfect film, Winning Dad excels in portraying the raw, sometimes uncomfortable, realities of familial love.
