In less than seven minutes, Second Thought delivers a powerful message about the consequences of the choices we make in love and dating. It contrasts the emotional void of shallow hookup culture with the potential for deep and lasting intimacy. Bezrukavenko and Stanley’s performances are heartwarming, offering a raw and genuine portrayal of young men navigating the complexities of gay dating. Set in Provincetown, the film uses the town’s iconic imagery as a metaphor for the contrasts in the storyline—one path leading to missed opportunities and emotional vacancy, the other to the possibility of true happiness. While the film's decision to omit dialogue and natural sound in favor of an omnipresent musical score detracts somewhat from its emotional impact, Second Thought still manages to leave a lasting impression on viewers.
Second Thought (2024) is a short but potent film that captures the essence of gay dating in the era of Grindr. Directed by a young and talented team—Art Bezrukavenko, Chris Stanley, Jimmy Martin, and Kat Holm—the film paints a poignant portrait of two young men who meet in Provincetown for a brief encounter. Bezrukavenko and Stanley not only co-directed but also star in the film, giving life to characters who embody the highs and lows of hookup culture.
The film begins with Art and Chris meeting for what seems to be a typical Grindr hookup, but what follows is a poignant and reflective sequence that contrasts the two possible outcomes of such encounters. In one version, after their night together, one character blocks the other on the app, ending any chance for a meaningful connection and leaving a sense of emotional emptiness. This depiction mirrors the reality for many who engage in online dating, where people are often treated as disposable, and intimacy is fleeting.
However, the film doesn’t leave viewers in despair. It presents an alternative ending, one where Art and Chris could have forged a deeper, more significant bond. This contrast highlights the dichotomy between instant gratification and the yearning for genuine intimacy—a central theme in modern gay dating culture. Bezrukavenko and Stanley’s performances are honest and relatable, offering a rare glimpse into the emotional complexities of online dating.
One of the film’s standout elements is its setting. Provincetown, known for its vibrant LGBTQ+ culture, serves as a beautiful and symbolic backdrop. The filmmakers use the town’s scenic imagery to enhance the narrative, creating a visual metaphor for the choices and possibilities that the characters face. Those familiar with Provincetown will likely appreciate the visual nods and the deeper meaning behind the setting.
While Second Thought excels in its storytelling and visual symbolism, it falters slightly with its artistic choice to forgo dialogue or ambient sound. The film is carried entirely by its musical score, which, although effective in moments, can feel overbearing at times. This decision leaves the film feeling more like a music video than an emotionally immersive narrative, where dialogue or natural sounds could have helped ground the characters’ emotional journeys.
Despite this minor flaw, Second Thought succeeds in delivering a powerful message about the consequences of shallow behavior versus the rewards of earnest connection. It resonates strongly with its target audience, offering a raw portrayal of the complexities of hookup culture and the potential for meaningful love. The film’s sharp cinematography, coupled with its thought-provoking narrative, makes it a significant contribution to LGBTQ+ cinema.
