“Truth,” directed by Rob Moretti, attempts to weave a tale of romance, deceit, and psychological turmoil, but ultimately falls short of its ambitions. The film centers around Caleb, portrayed by former gay porn star Sean Paul Lockhart, who finds himself entangled in a web of lies and manipulation.
Lockhart’s performance as Caleb, an abuse survivor grappling with trust issues, showcases glimpses of his talent beyond his adult film career. However, the film’s disjointed narrative and lackluster execution hinder his ability to shine. Despite Lockhart’s potential, even a performer of Montgomery Clift’s caliber would struggle to salvage the film’s flawed script and direction.
The story unfolds through a series of desaturated flashbacks, revealing Caleb’s troubled past, including an abusive alcoholic mother and a recent crisis involving a kitchen knife. As Caleb navigates his tumultuous relationship with Jeremy, played by Moretti himself, the plot veers into predictable territory. The revelation of Jeremy’s deception—a wife and impending fatherhood—feels contrived, lacking the emotional impact it strives to achieve.
While the film attempts to compensate for its shortcomings with gratuitous beefcake shots, Lockhart’s previous successes in roles such as “Judas Kiss” demonstrate his potential for more nuanced performances. Unfortunately, “Truth” fails to provide him with the necessary material to showcase his talents effectively.
The film’s cinematography, overseen by D.A. Santos, falls flat, with visuals that fail to captivate or immerse the audience. The accompanying dramatic score further detracts from the viewing experience, bordering on absurdity and overwhelming the onscreen action.
Overall, “Truth” is a disappointing endeavor that squanders its potential. Despite Lockhart’s presence and the film’s provocative subject matter, the lack of coherent storytelling and compelling direction leave viewers longing for substance. While Lockhart may yet prove himself in future roles, “Truth” serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of strong writing and direction in cinematic endeavors.